Charlie Rose had two articulate Iraqi's on to explain what is happening in Iraq and what America should do to help the Iraqi people. Glenn Greenwald shows the segment. Go watch it.
The several things that I particularly recall are one of the two men saying that America first destroyed the Iraqi nation after the Persian Gulf War with the bombings of infrastructure and the sanctions, then in the 2003 invasion they did everything wrong. The Americans are responsible for unleashing the internal strife in Iraq and for destroying any government that could have controlled it.
The Americans can't do anything to improve things. They have no credibility as protectors of democracy since they support dictatorships like Saudi Arabia and Egypt, and they don't know what they are doing even if they had good intentions, which the one Iraqi doubts.
The Sunnis were hired to attack al Qaeda in Iraq, but before the Americans invaded in 2003, there was no al Qaeda in Iraa. The Americans created those terrorists.
There's a lot more, all negative towards the American occupation. Why is this important? As Glenn Greenwald points out strongly, the view of Iraqis themselves are simply never presented in the American media.
I am not surprised at what the two Iraqis say, since I have read Graham Greene's novel "The Ugly American." the story is as true today in the Middle East as it was in Southeast Asia in the 1950's.
I have written several times that Iraq is a great Kabuki theater that presents plays to the American audience and that our leaders interpret for their own political purposes. What's really happening behind the curtains of the stage isn't known to our leaders, nor do they want it known. The only things we are getting from the American government is the information and lies they want to feed it for internal American political responses. Besides giving Bush the opportunity to be a "War President" and Cheney the opportunity to use the American military in the Middle East to influence oil flow, nothing else in Iraq matters to the current American government, and no one in any position of power has any expertise in Iraq, nor to they want it.
When you watch the TV clip, listen especially for the description of what is really happening in Iraq and how the two Iraqi's think we got there. I'd doubt their guess as to what we might to for Iraq other than getting out ASAP is any better than the guess of the American political or military leaders. We are simply in over our heads there, and we were before we stupidly sent in troops.
Per FEC regulations, this is an online magazine for political reports, analysis & opinion. New name, same magazine. See Explanation.
Showing posts with label Republican War in Iraq. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Republican War in Iraq. Show all posts
Wednesday, March 26, 2008
Thursday, January 31, 2008
Bush is leaving America a gutted Army
One thing that Bush has succeeded in doing is destroying the effectiveness of the U.S. Army. Dana Priest of the Washington Post explains what what has become of the Army:
The next President of the U.S. will enter office without any significant ground military capability to depend on. Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld have used it up in their failed military adventures.
How is McCain going to propose to rebuild the Army Bush has gutted, now the Bush has also driven the U.S. into Recession?
Suicides among active-duty soldiers in 2007 reached their highest level since the Army began keeping such records in 1980, according to a draft internal study obtained by The Washington Post. Last year, 121 soldiers took their own lives, nearly 20 percent more than in 2006.America would not have accepted a draft to fight in Iraq. Bush knew that and never tried to get one, nor did he every try to fund the war. He has just borrowed the money to pay the bills and used up the superb volunteer Army he inherited from Bill Clinton.
At the same time, the number of attempted suicides or self-inflicted injuries in the Army has jumped sixfold since the Iraq war began. Last year, about 2,100 soldiers injured themselves or attempted suicide, compared with about 350 in 2002, according to the U.S. Army Medical Command Suicide Prevention Action Plan.
The Army was unprepared for the high number of suicides and cases of post-traumatic stress disorder among its troops, as the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have continued far longer than anticipated. Many Army posts still do not offer enough individual counseling and some soldiers suffering psychological problems complain that they are stigmatized by commanders. Over the past year, four high-level commissions have recommended reforms and Congress has given the military hundreds of millions of dollars to improve its mental health care, but critics charge that significant progress has not been made.
The conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan have placed severe stress on the Army, caused in part by repeated and lengthened deployments. Historically, suicide rates tend to decrease when soldiers are in conflicts overseas, but that trend has reversed in recent years. From a suicide rate of 9.8 per 100,000 active-duty soldiers in 2001 -- the lowest rate on record -- the Army reached an all-time high of 17.5 suicides per 100,000 active-duty soldiers in 2006.
Last year, twice as many soldier suicides occurred in the United States than in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Col. Elspeth Cameron Ritchie, the Army's top psychiatrist and author of the study, said that suicides and attempted suicides "are continuing to rise despite a lot of things we're doing now and have been doing." Ritchie added: "We need to improve training and education. We need to improve our capacity to provide behavioral health care."
Ritchie's team conducted more than 200 interviews in the United States and overseas, and found that the common factors in suicides and attempted suicides include failed personal relationships; legal, financial or occupational problems; and the frequency and length of overseas deployments.
The next President of the U.S. will enter office without any significant ground military capability to depend on. Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld have used it up in their failed military adventures.
How is McCain going to propose to rebuild the Army Bush has gutted, now the Bush has also driven the U.S. into Recession?
Labels:
Army,
Bush,
Iraq War,
Occupation of Iraq,
Republican War in Iraq
Friday, November 02, 2007
Here's what it feels like to be an Iraqi refugee
Go read this post at Baghdad Burning. This is what America has done to Iraq.
Iraq was not any threat to America. It's invasion was to be a demonstration project for the nations of the Middle East who did not follow orders given by the American government. The last remaining reason the conservatives offer to justify the invasion of Iraq is 2003 is "We had to remove Saddam!" Every other alleged reason has withered in the face of the facts - facts the Bush administration knew and hid from the public or smothered with lies.
Well, Saddam is gone. This article shows the cost of his removal.
The alleged benefit is not worth the cost.
Next Bush wants to attack Iran. If he does, history demonstrates that reasons Bush offer will turn out to be lies, and history demonstrates that the attack will not be worth the cost.
Iraq was not any threat to America. It's invasion was to be a demonstration project for the nations of the Middle East who did not follow orders given by the American government. The last remaining reason the conservatives offer to justify the invasion of Iraq is 2003 is "We had to remove Saddam!" Every other alleged reason has withered in the face of the facts - facts the Bush administration knew and hid from the public or smothered with lies.
Well, Saddam is gone. This article shows the cost of his removal.
The alleged benefit is not worth the cost.
Next Bush wants to attack Iran. If he does, history demonstrates that reasons Bush offer will turn out to be lies, and history demonstrates that the attack will not be worth the cost.
Saturday, October 06, 2007
Support the troops - Republican style
The Wisconsin Army National Guard is leading the Army in the amount of time served in Iraq. After several extensions, the 1st Brigade Combat Team of the 34th Infantry Division, Minnesota National Guard, has served 22 months in Iraq, more time than any other Army unit in the military. They are also finding out how how their service is rewarded, as many of them are being screwed over in GI Bill educational benefits - by design.
For a National Guard unit there are two levels of GI Bill educational benefits. One level is for soldiers who served less than two years and another, much more generous is for soldiers who have served two years and over. The difference is determined by how many days were served on active duty, with two years being 730 or more days of active duty. When the 2600 soldiers of the 1/34 Infantry came home and was demobilized recently, they learned that a large number of them were released from active duty with only 729 days total duty, one day short of eligibility for the higher educational benefits under the G.I. Bill.
There are a number of differences between the two levels of benefits, but one of the differences is that for students who take full time training the monthly benefit for service of 729 days or less is $282 a month. For service of 730 days or more, it is $800 a month. The Minnesota National Guard believes that any soldier who served 20 months or more in Iraq should get the higher benefit.
The fact that so many were demobilized exactly one day short of eligibility for the higher benefit strongly suggests that the timing was no accident. That single day will save the Army a lot of GI Bill money. Who cares that they are the longest serving combat military unit in the Republican War in Iraq?
This is how the Republican support the troops.
[Source: Associated Press.]
For a National Guard unit there are two levels of GI Bill educational benefits. One level is for soldiers who served less than two years and another, much more generous is for soldiers who have served two years and over. The difference is determined by how many days were served on active duty, with two years being 730 or more days of active duty. When the 2600 soldiers of the 1/34 Infantry came home and was demobilized recently, they learned that a large number of them were released from active duty with only 729 days total duty, one day short of eligibility for the higher educational benefits under the G.I. Bill.
There are a number of differences between the two levels of benefits, but one of the differences is that for students who take full time training the monthly benefit for service of 729 days or less is $282 a month. For service of 730 days or more, it is $800 a month. The Minnesota National Guard believes that any soldier who served 20 months or more in Iraq should get the higher benefit.
The fact that so many were demobilized exactly one day short of eligibility for the higher benefit strongly suggests that the timing was no accident. That single day will save the Army a lot of GI Bill money. Who cares that they are the longest serving combat military unit in the Republican War in Iraq?
This is how the Republican support the troops.
[Source: Associated Press.]
Wednesday, September 12, 2007
Al Qaeda is not al Qaeda in Iraq - Bush wants them confused
James Wimberly reports on the way the testimony from Petreaus and Crocker dropped the phrase "al Qaeda in Iraq" (AQI) in favor of the less accurate "al Qaeda."
Osama bin Laden's al Qaeda attacked the United States on 9/11.
Al Qaeda in Iraq is an organization created in Northern Iraq by the Jordanian criminal Abu Musab al-Zarqawi. The organization was originally named Jama'at al-Tawhid wal-Jihad (Group of Monotheism and the Holy Struggle). There has never been a close association between AQI and al Qaeda. AQI has no record of attempting to attack Americans in America and no known capability or motivation to do so.
Confusing the two groups serves only to justify the lies used to drag America into the unnecessary war in Iraq. It is a Republican ploy to attempt to avoid responsibility for the greatest single foreign policy blunder ever made by an American President.
So what? Here's what, from TPM:
This administration is filled with decision-makers who believe their own propaganda, chief among them being Bush himself.
Don Rumsfeld felt that the American military was the most powerful in the world because it could deliver combat power anywhere in the world and take out targets almost anywhere. Unfortunately, combat power does not win a counter-insurgency. In fact, the inappropriate use of that combat power has the effect of alienating the population who has to be convinced to oppose the insurgents. That means that a counter-insurgency is at its base dependent on large quantities of accurate and honest Intelligence.
When the decision-makers doesn't understand the nature of the war they are fighting and depend on what their own propaganda says to make decisions in the war, then the insurgents can be expected to win.
That's why it is critically important to distinguish between al Qaeda and al Qaeda in Iraq. The Bush administration has shown repeatedly that it cannot make those fine distinctions. That is why Petreaus and Crocker were on Capital hill the last two days trying to dress up conflicting statistics to show that there is "Light at the end of the tunnel" in Iraq. But it's a road show selling a charade.
With someone else as President besides Bush and with Dick Cheney absent, the occupation of Iraq might possibly have muddled through to a result that would not be so starkly a total failure as the occupation of Iraq has shown itself to be. We'll never know. With them there, there is no possibility of anything that can even be papered over to resemble success.
Osama bin Laden's al Qaeda attacked the United States on 9/11.
Al Qaeda in Iraq is an organization created in Northern Iraq by the Jordanian criminal Abu Musab al-Zarqawi. The organization was originally named Jama'at al-Tawhid wal-Jihad (Group of Monotheism and the Holy Struggle). There has never been a close association between AQI and al Qaeda. AQI has no record of attempting to attack Americans in America and no known capability or motivation to do so.
Confusing the two groups serves only to justify the lies used to drag America into the unnecessary war in Iraq. It is a Republican ploy to attempt to avoid responsibility for the greatest single foreign policy blunder ever made by an American President.
So what? Here's what, from TPM:
As Spencer Ackerman notes, the non-al-Qaeda Sunni insurgents have accounted for most of the U.S. military casualties in Iraq. There likely has been some reduction in Sunni insurgent violence against U.S. troops in Anbar this year, and in fact the U.S. strategy of joining with the Anbar Sunnis against al Qaeda in Iraq is probably part of the reason Petraeus is downplayng the Sunni insurgency at the moment.An strong argument can be made that the confusion of various enemy groups and conflation of them into al Qaeda is (and has been) a propaganda tool used by the Bush administration to fool the American public into believing that there was a legitimate 9/11-related reason for invading Iraq in the first place and then for convincing the American public to keep troops in Iraq when the mismanagement of the occupation by Jerry Bremer and the CPA allowed the insurgency to develop. But there is more.
But whatever the short-term exigency, this has been a conflict marked by our inability, unwillingness, or idealogical aversion toward accurately identifying our enemies. Even the use of the blanket term "enemy" is misleading in a conflict with multiple competing interests, where alliances come and go, and in which the enemy of thy enemy is not necessarily thy friend. [Snip}
...the strategic and tactical miscalculations arising from the misidentification, to put it charitably, of the competing groups there crippled whatever chance there was of the U.S. effort succeeding.
This administration is filled with decision-makers who believe their own propaganda, chief among them being Bush himself.
Don Rumsfeld felt that the American military was the most powerful in the world because it could deliver combat power anywhere in the world and take out targets almost anywhere. Unfortunately, combat power does not win a counter-insurgency. In fact, the inappropriate use of that combat power has the effect of alienating the population who has to be convinced to oppose the insurgents. That means that a counter-insurgency is at its base dependent on large quantities of accurate and honest Intelligence.
When the decision-makers doesn't understand the nature of the war they are fighting and depend on what their own propaganda says to make decisions in the war, then the insurgents can be expected to win.
That's why it is critically important to distinguish between al Qaeda and al Qaeda in Iraq. The Bush administration has shown repeatedly that it cannot make those fine distinctions. That is why Petreaus and Crocker were on Capital hill the last two days trying to dress up conflicting statistics to show that there is "Light at the end of the tunnel" in Iraq. But it's a road show selling a charade.
With someone else as President besides Bush and with Dick Cheney absent, the occupation of Iraq might possibly have muddled through to a result that would not be so starkly a total failure as the occupation of Iraq has shown itself to be. We'll never know. With them there, there is no possibility of anything that can even be papered over to resemble success.
Two of seven 82d Airborne sargeants dead in Iraq
On August 19th the New York Times published an OpEd written by seven 82d Airborne Division sergeants nearing the end of their tours in Iraq.
This morning Greg Mitchell of Editor & Publisher reports that two of those seven soldiers were killed in a vehicle accident in Western Baghdad. Sgt. Omar Mora (from Texas City, TX) and Sgt. Yance Gray (Ismay, MT) died Monday. Each is survived by a wife and daughter.
Another of the seven, Staff Sergeant Jeremy Murphy, an Army Ranger and reconnaissance team leader, was shot in the head as the OpEd was being prepared for publication last August. He is being treated in a military hospital in the United States and is expected to survive.
This morning Greg Mitchell of Editor & Publisher reports that two of those seven soldiers were killed in a vehicle accident in Western Baghdad. Sgt. Omar Mora (from Texas City, TX) and Sgt. Yance Gray (Ismay, MT) died Monday. Each is survived by a wife and daughter.
Another of the seven, Staff Sergeant Jeremy Murphy, an Army Ranger and reconnaissance team leader, was shot in the head as the OpEd was being prepared for publication last August. He is being treated in a military hospital in the United States and is expected to survive.
Labels:
Army,
Casualties,
Occupation of Iraq,
Republican War in Iraq
Sunday, September 09, 2007
Kevin Drum tracks Republican Hawk evolution
This is definitely one of Kevin Drum's more insightful posts. He tracks how the Republican Hawks have evolved to succeed in the varying and rapidly downward spiralling environment of the Republican war in Iraq. From primitive "War Hawks", they have evolved first to become "Pottery Barn Hawks." But as the Republican War in Iraq spiraled even further downward, they have now morphed into what Kevin calls "Chaos Hawks." Here is Kevin's analysis:
I doubt it. There is little reason to believe that a modern "Chaos Hawk" could no longer interbreed with a primitive "War Hawk."
In the beginning were the War Hawks, and much did they counsel the powerful to do battle against the evildoer Saddam. Then came the war, and the looting, and the Heritage Foundation hordes, and the hawks lamented exceeding loud and many soon repented of their ways. Yea, verily, they presently transformed themselves into Pottery Barn Hawks, eager to fix the disaster they had helped create and thus redeem themselves in the eyes of the faithful. In the fullness of time, though, the disaster ripened and flowered and became impossible of resolution, and the hawks despaired. Success had become unachievable, yea unto their own generation and the generation to come after them. In short, life sucked.One question Kevin does not address is whether the hawks have evolved into an entirely new species yet.
So what's a Pottery Barn hawk to do? The answer, lately, is: become a Chaos Hawk. First, admit that Iraq is hopeless, thus demonstrating that you're not completely out to lunch. After all, the surge has produced only tiny gains in a few highly localized areas and has no chance of replicating those successes on a wide scale. The Iraqi government is dysfunctional, the police forces are dysfunctional, the army is years away from competence, militias are engaged in a ruthless campaign of sectarian cleansing, infrastructure is declining, and refugees are fleeing the country at a rate of thousands per day.
Having admitted, however, that the odds of a military success in Iraq are almost impossibly long, Chaos Hawks nonetheless insist that the U.S. military needs to stay in Iraq for the foreseeable future. Why? Because if we leave the entire Middle East will become a bloodbath. Sunni and Shiite will engage in mutual genocide, oil fields will go up in flames, fundamentalist parties will take over, and al-Qaeda will have a safe haven bigger than the entire continent of Europe.
I doubt it. There is little reason to believe that a modern "Chaos Hawk" could no longer interbreed with a primitive "War Hawk."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)