Showing posts with label Nomination. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nomination. Show all posts

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Well. Wasn't Saturday interesting. So now what?

Here's my take on the Saturday political games from the perspective of the Republican and Democratic nomination activities yesterday, and then I will discuss how I think the general election is beginning to shape up.

Republicans • Democrats• Vice Presidents • Election fundamentals
[Link down - Arrow back]

Republicans

One thing is clear from Saturday. While McCain is the Republican frontrunner, and the man I think will ultimately win the Republican nomination, the Washington state caucuses showed that the Republican Party really doesn't like him. Even after Romney formally got out of the race, McCain couldn't decisively beat him. Nor could McCain decisively defeat the two clearly self-limited other candidates, Huckabee and Ron Paul.

I can't help but wonder. Would the Washington state Republicans have chosen "None of the above" over any of the candidates they did vote for?

That's not to say that the Republicans won't put a strong campaign together behind McCain for November in the next eight-plus months.

Still, the only thing that I can see the Republicans are getting out of the 2008 nomination races is a really politically powerful Christian fundamentalist right-wing political leader who will be with us for decades. I'd say Huckabee has picked up the mantle of Billy Graham, John Rushdoony, Jerry Falwell, and Pat Robertson and rather thoroughly displaced James Dobson. Huckabee and the Discovery Institute will be with us for the foreseeable future trying to turn America into a Dominionist theocracy, and the 2008 Republican nomination campaigns has placed Huckabee at the top of that heap. Except for Billy Graham (who was just a politically powerful preacher) the rest are actively opposed to America under the Constitution and need to be carefully watched.

Ron Paul, unsurprisingly, is going nowhere in the Republican race for the nomination. Somewhat to my surprise, he has announced that he will not run on a third party. The news report point out that he needs to return to his congressional district and head off a primary challenge, so I guess he doesn't want to give up his Congressional seat.

Democrats

Obama clearly had a very good day Saturday, but he isn't going to put the nomination away before the Democratic convention, just as Hillary won't. Each need 2025 delegates to win the nomination outright, each has something in the ball park of 1000 delegates, and only about 1400 remain to be won in the remaining primaries and caucuses. The Democratic nomination for President is essentially a tie in the primaries and caucuses, so the decision will come down to the Superdelegates.

As good as Saturday was for Obama, Hispanics are not voting for an African-American. The big states remaining on the Democratic primary - caucus calendar are Ohio (161 delegates), Texas (228 delegates), Pennsylvania (188 delegates) and North Carolina (134 delegates). Hillary has a better organization and longer relations in Texas, plus she has courted the Hispanic vote here. Obama is unlikely to get over a third of the Texas delegates (~76). Depending on Black turnout in North Carolina, give him two-thirds there (~90) and split Ohio and Pennsylvania, maybe an edge to Obama. (~180). So give Obama 346 of the 657 delegates, and Hillary 311. That's roughly 52% Obama to 48% Hillary.

Of 657 delegates, 20% will be Superdelegates, so only about 525 are up for grabs. Neither is going to put the nomination away. The Superdelegates will decide. This is not a bad thing for the Democratic Party. As I posted Friday:
I really think it is coming down to an effective tie for delegates when the Democratic voters and caucus-goers are counted, so the final decision is going to the 20% Superdelegates at the convention. Those are Democratic Party professionals and they will choose the person with the greatest likelihood of coattails. Since that will have the greatest power to build the Democratic Party, that's the way the decision needs to be made.

Undemocratic? Forget such kneejerk ideological reactions. There is more to consider than just voter impressions, especially when they are essentially tied. There is also the question of how to build a better Democratic Party, one able to prevent the conservatives from destroying America as it has for the last thirty to forty years. Jimmy Carter's worst flaw as President was that he did nothing to build the Democratic Party at a time when the Goldwaterites, John Birchers and unreconstructed Nixonites were bringing the political evangelists and Reagan Democrat racists into the Republican Party and building the Reagan coalition. Party-building matters. A strong Democratic Party is better for America and for Americans in the long run. If the voters are essentially tied when it is time to choose a Presidential nominee, then it is appropriate for the party professionals to consider the realities of electoral politics. If the Superdelegates get it wrong, then American democracy will correct them on the first Tuesday in November. So as things look right now, the Superdelegates may make the final selection between Hillary and Obama, and that's not a bad thing to have happen. They really can't go wrong deciding between those two.
About the only argument that remains in play is which of the two, Hillary or Obama, can more easily defeat McCain. So with the Presidential nominees for each party relatively clear, it is probably time to consider Vice President choices.

Vice Presidential Choices

I had thought that Obama would be a good Vice Presidential candidate for Hillary. I don't think that Hillary would strengthen an Obama ticket, but that is pure opinion. Eric Alterman disagrees with me on Obama as Veep to Hillary. He also comments on Veep choice for McCain.
5) Running mates? Again, I dunno. Clinton/Obama in either combo makes no sense. The ticket needs a white male. Jim Webb would work well for either one. So would John Edwards, and Joe Biden. Chris Dodd makes a lot of sense for Obama but not for Clinton.

For McCain, if he's worried about Limbaugh-like lunatics staying home, he will have to go to his right flank and pick an anti-immigrant demagogue, though Huckabee could work here, he's also a high-risk choice because of his (endearing) personality quirks and total and complete lack of understanding of foreign affairs. Otherwise, he should go north and make himself competitive in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, though I don't have any names in mind for that. Tom Kean is too liberal and would be a Democrat anywhere else but the Northeast.
So that's where we are today. What about the general election?

The Election fundamentals

There are at least three major issues that are going to determine the outcome of this election. They are

Change, Security and The Economy.
Then how will the issues work out on
Election day?
[link down - Arrow back]

Change - The polls this eight months before the election are a waste of time. They tell us nothing. So look at the fundamentals. Americans want a change away from the conservative policies that have been destroying the American government and economy. both Hillary and Obama offer that, with Obama seen as the stronger of the two. McCain offers continuation, not change.

Security - Security is supposedly McCain's strongest issue. But is it? McCain is a stark raving mad militarist and Imperialist who never saw a war he didn't want America to fight. This, his legendary temper and his support by the Neocons and Joe Lieberman (who will happily support fighting any Arab anywhere any time) make McCain a prime candidate for "Goldwaterization." When the over two-thirds of Americans consider the Iraq adventure a major blunder in the first place and want America out as soon as possible, McCain may be swimming upstream. There's a limit to how long voters will vote against real needs out of fear.

Obama may have an edge over Hillary on the security issue because she voted for the Iraq war and he didn't. [No telling what he would have done had he been in the Senate, but that's the way it is.]

But speaking of the voter's real needs, there is the economy.

The Economy - No party that controlled the White House when the economy went into Recession during election year has seen their candidate win the Presidency. This has been true for the last century, and it isn't going to change. That makes the 2008 Presidential election one for the Democrats to lose, and they would have to work hard to do so. McCain has, if it is possible, negative credentials for dealing with the economy. His statement that he doesn't know much about it, but has bought Greenspan's book is just crying out for repeated replay in October.

The Bush administration is going to work hard to downplay America's economic problems, but they have gotten to obvious to be overlooked by most voters. Romney was their only chance to deal with the economic problems, and too many social Republicans just couldn't vote for a Mormon.

On the Democratic side, Hillary is the strongest of the two candidates for dealing with the economic problems. I haven't seen much indication that Obama is any better prepared than McCain is.

Election Day - Given those three issues, Security is the only one that McCain might be strong with, and his strength can be neutralized by exploiting his character, both his militarism and his temper. So America will get change, from conservatives to Democrats. The question is, Hillary or Obama?

The third issue, the economy, together with the Superdelegates reactions to the race, is going to probably determine that. Since it is now clear that the Democratic nomination is going to be determined by the Superdelegates, What motivates them? Local party strength.

The Superdelegates are going to look at which of the two has the strongest coattails. Hillary has the better economic credentials, and right now she has the in-depth long term national organization that the Superdelegates, considering local and state election outcomes, are likely to prefer to a roll of the dice on the Obama movement. So unless Obama creams Hillary for the next two months while simultaneously building a credible nationwide organization for the state and local elections, Hillary is going to be the choice of the Superdelegates.

A Hillary nomination will probably make the Presidential general election nastier, since the right-wing hates Hillary worse than they do an African-American candidate. That Hillary will get nastier treatment isn't clear, though, because an Obama nomination is going to bring out the right-wing Racists in force. In either case, the recession economy and the demand for change is going to be the political wind in the Democratic sails.

If Hillary gets the nomination, what happens to Obama? He wants really badly to be President, and he is quite young. He will be Hillary's presumed successor unless he messes up somehow. So he can be expected to throw his full weight behind Hillary's campaign in the general election.

Anyway, that's the way things seem to be stacking up as of today from my perspective.

Comments and criticism are encouraged.


You may notice that I have been playing with internal HTML links in this post. I wasn't sure that blogger would support them, but they do. Now that I know they work I'll try to use them to make my writing a little less bulky, turgid and intimidating. If you want shorter posts, forget it. That's just not me.

Apparently blogger's spell check feature is off, so I apologize for those spelling errors I have missed.

Wednesday, February 06, 2008

Obama for Veep

Armando, writing as Big Tent Democrat, makes a strong case that yesterday was the high water mark for Obama. He points out that Obama has been an insurgent candidate trying to knock off the front runner, and his media, momentum and endorsements put him in the position on Super Tuesday where, if he could win at least one of the large states (California, Massachusetts, New Jersey or New York) he might be able to keep the momentum going forward and defeat Hillary. Unfortunately, Obama failed to get any of those states. Since Clinton is preferred by the Hispanics and White women, Texas is probably out of his reach also. Without at least one of those five very large states, Obama will not get the nomination. Armand puts it this way: "He can not win women, Latinos, older voters and lower income non-African Americans. The Obama coalition is simply not enough".

That analysis seems quite persuasive to me. I don't think that Texas is going to be changed enough in the next month for Obama to win. Since Texas has 28 different television markets, any fast change in the attitudes here are extremely unlikely. Any attempt to make such a change is prohibitively expensive. (California, I am told, has only four TV markets.)

That's going to leave Obama in an interesting position as the convention approaches. It is clear that the strongest Democratic ticket would be Clinton/Obama. It is also very clear that Obama wants to run for the Presidency. If he can't do it this year, he will have a much better shot at it later from the position of Vice President than he would from being just another Senator.

I've heard rumors that Clinton and Obama don't like each other that much, and that would prevent him from accepting the position of Vice President on the Democratic ticket. That's what people thought in 1960 when Kennedy took the Democratic nomination from Lyndon Johnson, too, and it didn't stop LBJ from taking the job. Even if there is bad blood, which I consider more of a media artifact to gin up conflict and make stories more interesting than it is a fact, if Clinton gets the nomination and offers the position of vice President on the ticket to Obama, he'd be a fool not to take it. And, since the Democratic nomination looks like it is coming down to the decision of the roughly 20% superdelegates, I think those professionals will push both individuals into such an arrangement.

A race between Clinton/Obama and McCain/(Huckabee?) would pit the strongest Democratic coalition against the a Republican coalition that leaves out the extremists conservatives but otherwise carries the moderate Republicans and the evangelists, which is probably the strongest possible Republican coalition. And the extremist conservatives are not going to sit on their hands and not vote when they have a chance to vote against both Hillary and a Black Democrat at the same time. So the only people to be left out on the Republican side are the extremist right-wing talk radio hosts and Mitt Romney.

The comparative turnout between the Democrats and the Republicans in the Primaries and caucuses indicates that a Democratic win in November is very likely.

The other thing that is extremely likely is that the wealthy Republicans who hate losing and who fund swift boat campaigns will be out in force, making this the most nasty Presidential election in the memory of living voters. I don't think they will change the election dynamics this time, except possibly against the Republicans. One of the main things that Obama has had going for him as a candidate is his promise to make elections about the future of America instead of fighting off nasty attacks, and I think the climate this election is going to one in which swift boat attacks become a negative for the candidate they are supposed to support.

And no, I don't think that the Democrats do the same thing, certainly not as blatantly. These dirty tricks are a trademark of Republican politics as played by Lee Atwater and Karl Rove.

But this isn't a prediction. It's a possible scenario.

Thursday, March 08, 2007

Politics TV refuses to cover FOX Democratic debate

The National Democratic Party has scheduled a debate for Democratic candidates for the nomination for President, to be held in Nevada (home of Harry Reid, Senate Majority Leader) and to be controlled and broadcast by FOX "News" (the propaganda arm of the radical right-wing of the Republican Party.)

FOX ceased long ago to be a news organization, and is as much an enemy of America as Dick Cheney, his NeoCons, and al Qaeda. Why the Democratic Party would give them the contract to operate and broadcast a pre-primary debate I find it hard to imagine.

Politics TV, the excellent webcasting organization who has brought us the Jane, Marcy & Others Show from the Libby Trial has refused to contract with FOX to cover that debate. Here is the explanation that Politics TV presented.

Politics TV has got it right. What is wrong with Harry Reid?