Showing posts with label Baghdad. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Baghdad. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 03, 2007

State Department report on Blackwater's Baghdad killings was written by a Blackwater contract employee.

The Department of State Bureau of Diplomatic Security issued a report on the now famous incident in which Blackwater security personnel killed a number of civilians in downtown Baghdad. It seems that the individual who investigated the incident and wrote the report was Darren Hanner, RSO TOC Watch Officer, Baghdad.

Mark Kleiman points out that Darren Hanner is a contract employee from Blackwater.

The FBI is sending a team to Baghdad to investigate the incident. I hear that the FBI team investigating the actions of Blackwater in Baghdad will be given security services by Blackwater security personnel.

This Blackwater stuff is getting out of hand.

Monday, September 03, 2007

Why there are fewer civilian deaths in Baghdad now.

Steve Benen at TPM provides an explanation for why civilian casualties are down in Baghdad compared to last Fall before the "surge" started.

While the U.S. was increasing the number of American troops operating inside Baghdad, the Shiites were conducting ethnic cleansing. The Sunnis who used to dominate western Baghdad are now essentially gone, and are replaced with Shiites. From Newsweek:
When Gen. David Petraeus goes before Congress next week to report on the progress of the surge, he may cite a decline in insurgent attacks in Baghdad as one marker of success. In fact, part of the reason behind the decline is how far the Shiite militias' cleansing of Baghdad has progressed: they've essentially won.
Steve then quotes Matt Yglesias:
"Maybe Bush can change his line to the idea that if we just keep staying the course for 4 or 5 more years, casualties will drop massively because everyone will already be dead or displaced. Or maybe someone can explain to me again about how we can't leave Iraq because of the ethnic cleansing that'll happen without us around."
We aren't keeping our troops in Iraq to prevent ethnic cleansing. When the ethnic cleansing in Iraq is finished the sectarian violence will end, and we can declare victory and get out. We are watching the ethnic cleansing go on and hoping that it will bail us out.

Kevin Drum also discusses the Newsweek article. He points out the fact that
"I've mentioned in passing once or twice before that one possible way for Iraq's civil war to end is simply through attrition. If we just wait it out long enough, eventually someone will win and the fighting will stop — regardless of what the United States Army does or doesn't do."
It does seem pretty self-evident - If we just stay and allow our military people to continue in the occupation, ultimately the problems there will go away. All we have to do is ignore the costs and fail to ask what "winning" will look like.

Thursday, April 12, 2007

Who to believe, who to believe?

We get this report (*) today from Baghdad:
BAGHDAD 12/04/2007 17:25

Three people, including two lawmakers, were killed on Thursday when a suicide bomber wearing an explosive vest blew himself up in the canteen in the Iraqi parliament building, a security official said.
but we have Senator John McCain walking around in the market in Baghdad outside the Green Zone and telling us how safe it is, how much Baghdad has improved.

Does this mean that the most dangeroud place in Baghdad now is INSIDE the Green Zone?

If not, then I have unresolved cognitive dissonance.

[(*) Referred from Informed Comment by Juan Cole.]

Monday, March 12, 2007

We will leave Iraq - what then? Rolling Stone gets answers.

Sooner or later we will leave Iraq. The "Surge" is out last gasp. The right-wing propaganda outlets are pointing out that the sectarian strife seems to be going down in Baghdad some, but the Sunni car bombs aren't. We are getting more of them.

My best guess is that the Mahdi Militia has gone quiet while we are trying to pacify Baghdad, and that explains the relative sectarian quiet. But it's not the kind of "quiet" that suggests the end of the war is coming. It is the kind of "quiet" that means they are waiting us out and will reappear as soon as the U.S. pulls out. Very likely the Iraqi army soldiers who are with us to pacify Baghdad will then move over to the Mahdi Militia and the real sectarian strife will start.

The Mahdi Militia can outwait us. We can't outwait them. We don't have enough at stake to stay permanently. Sooner or later, we WILL leave. Then what?

Rolling Stone gathered a group of experts and they have addressed three scenarios.
  1. BEST-CASE SCENARIO
  2. MOST LIKELY SCENARIO
  3. WORST-CASE SCENARIO
Go read it.

Or you might, for fun, match up three of these brief summary descriptions with the three scenarios:
  • ?. Years of Ethnic Cleansing and war with Iran.
  • ?. Without the U.S. military to inflame people, there will be quick partition and a strong man government.
  • ?. World War III.
  • ?. Civil War in Iraq and a stronger al Qaeda.
  • ?. War between Shia and Sunni Middle East nations.
  • ?. The Middle Class will return and create a democracy in Iraq.
The answers will be found in the article.

Comments and opinions will be welcomed. Reasons for opinions are preferred, not just quotes from experts.