Showing posts with label Political Polling. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Political Polling. Show all posts

Saturday, October 03, 2009

Don't trust Strategic Vision's reported poll numbers

How likely is it that Strategic Vision LLC has just been making up the numbers it reports? The New York Times reports:
news organizations are rethinking their use of Strategic Vision’s numbers after the company was reprimanded [* See below] last week by a professional association of pollsters for failing to disclose “essential facts” about its methods.
[...]
Strategic Vision was founded by Mr. Johnson and his wife, Laura Ward, as a Republican-leaning mom-and-pop public relations company in 2002. In 2004, the company branched out into polling, focusing on Senate and presidential races. One of its clients is the Friedman Foundation for Educational Choice, based in Indiana, which supports the use of government vouchers to send children to private schools.

Like many of its competitors, Strategic Vision issued polls it said were self-financed, as a way of attracting attention and clients. The company was successful in part because its polling was prolific and was often among the earliest on a given race, like the one in which Ralph Reed, former executive director of the Christian Coalition, ran for lieutenant governor of Georgia in 2006.

Early on, questions were raised about how such a small firm could conduct so many self-financed polls, but Mr. Johnson, a frequent commentator on Fox News, said they accounted for the company’s entire marketing budget. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution repeatedly requested supporting documentation for the poll results but never received any, said James A. Mallory, senior managing editor. A spokeswoman for CNN said it had declined for years to use Strategic Vision’s polls.
[...]
The reprimand, by
[*] the American Association for Public Opinion Research, stemmed from an investigation it conducted after many polls showed Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton trailing in the run-up to the 2008 Democratic presidential primary in New Hampshire, where she went on to win. The association requested minimal information from 21 polling companies that, according to its professional guidelines, all polls should disclose, including sample size, response rate and polling dates.

Strategic Vision was the only company that did not provide the information, prompting a complaint filed with the association.
Let's see. New company. No track record. Based on a lot of publicity by the owner. Right-wing oriented. Refuses to provide sample size, response rate and polling dates which are minimal data for evaluating a sample poll.

That's a company to disbelieve whenever its name is associated with any poll.

They'll do something about this report quickly. My bet is that they will soon change the name of their company.

Friday, November 07, 2008

What makes Republicans afraid of the media?

This is an interesting observation from an exit pollster.
Since like forever, people have been wondering why exit polls are so fucked up that they underrepresent Republicans by a little under two percent. Why are Republicans "reluctant?" [Snip]

It is very simply because Republicans don't trust the media. When people in my precinct saw network logos on my badge, they refused to participate, in a few cases after they had initially agreed to do so. One even suspected I would change his answers.

Republicans have weird beliefs which lead them to behave strangely. It's an ancient story. But in this case, we don't need an elaborate apparatus of behavioral science to tell us why Republicans won't submit their precious opinions to news orgs: they're afraid they'll be made to seem foolish.
I can see that. Take social conservatives. They are often faith-based religious extremists who ignore and oppose things that most of the mainstream considered settled fact. Evolution is an example. Every time they tell what they really believe they take flack from those with mainstream beliefs. The financial conservatives believe in things like destroying Social Security to improve the economy. They face the same reaction. The Libertarians are highly faith-based, though to tell them that will be to start an argument. And NeoCons simply completely disbelieve in most diplomacy. Troops cause real changes, diplomacy is useless because your enemies will not do what you want/demand unless you hold a gun to their head.

The list is almost endless. I can really see many such people preferring not to talk to pollsters for fear that their opinions will be misrepresented, altered in the report or even laughed at. Most Republicans who believe such things that seem strange to mainstream individuals are not combative people any more than most of us are, so they believe what they believe and prefer not to expose it to others they don't know.

That's my best guess, anyway. As I say, the observation is quite interesting.

Monday, July 23, 2007

What is "Mainstream" America?

Kevin Drum lists the results from Washington Post polls on selected extremely important issues in an effort to determine what is really mainstream attitude today:
  • 78% think George Bush is too unwilling to change policies in Iraq.
  • 55% support legislation to withdraw from Iraq by next spring.
  • 55% trust congressional Democrats on the war (only 32% trust Bush).
  • 62% think Congress should have the final say about when to withdraw troops.
  • 49% think Democrats have done too little to get Bush to change his Iraq policy (only 17% think they've done too much).
What this means is that there are two groups of extremists in America today. The first group is the Republican Party. The second group is the Washington, D.C. pundit corps.

The Democratic Party today represents mainstream American attitudes. The Republicans and the D.C. Pundits are the real extremists in America today.

Wednesday, May 09, 2007

Here's what a Super-Pollster does for a campaign

Mark Schmitt describes what functions a Super-pollster performs for a political campaign. Then he explains what the Super-Pollster Mark Penn ("Worldwide President and CEO" of Burson-Marsteller, the fifth-largest public relations firm) does and how he does it. He starts his commentary from the excellent article in the Nation by Ari Berman.

This is definitely worth reading. Burson-Marsteller's website is found here.